Genevieve Lacasse

Cherrie would begin a feud with Portia Perez after both competitors lost a three-way match to Tomoka Nakagawa at Femmes Fatales VII, which included a one-on-one victory over Perez at Femmes Fatales VIII on March 10, 2012. At Femmes Fatales IX on July 7, Cherrie teamed with Cherry Bomb to form "The Cherries" in a losing effort to Perez and her Canadian Ninjas partner, Nicole Matthews, in a #1 Contender's Match for the SHIMMER Tag Team Championship. After the match ended, Cherry Bomb turned heel and attacked Cherrie; blaming her for the loss. This led to a one-on-one match between the former partners at Part 1 of Femmes Fatales X, which Cherrie won. At Part 2, Cherrie gained a DQ win over Saraya Knight after Knight delivered a low-blow. On July 6, 2013, Cherrie had an opportunity at the NCW Femmes Fatales Championship, losing to Mercedes Martinez at Femmes Fatales XII. At Femmes Fatales XIII, Cherrie teamed with LuFisto in defeating Mercedes Martinez and Cheerleader Melissa in a No DQ tag team match.

On June 16, 2012, Cherrie appeared for Women Superstars Uncensored's Uncensored Rumble V as a villainess in a losing effort against Kalamity for the NCW Femmes Fatales Championship. On October 27, 2012, Cherrie made an appearance for SHIMMER Women Athletes, losing to Angelus Layne in a dark match at Volume 49. The following day, Cherrie and Kira defeated December and Heidi Lovelace in a dark match at Volume 51.